On 4 November, the right to own a small car in Singapore cost $139,001. You get a certificate. It expires in 10 years. The car is extra.
The weird part is which category broke the record. Cat A, the one meant for small, mass-market cars, closed higher than Cat B for the big ones ($132,334). The day before, the transport minister told Parliament we can’t really grow the car population much further. And the government is working on yet another fix.
I made a video on how we got here. Watch it, or read the short version below.
In 1990, it fit on one MRT ride
Before COE, Singapore tried raising road taxes to slow car growth. People just paid up. So in May 1990 the government tried something bold. Fix the number of cars. Auction the right to own one. Let price decide who gets it.
That was the whole system. You could explain it to your grandmother on one MRT ride.
And to be fair, it worked. Compare a Monday morning on the PIE with Jakarta or Bangkok. Car growth has been frozen at zero since February 2018. In November 2008, during the financial crisis, a Cat A COE went for $2. Less than your kopi peng.
Then we started cooking
The best way I can describe the next 36 years is soup. You taste it, not sweet enough, so you add sugar. Now it’s too sweet, so you add salt. Too salty, a bit more sugar. Every spoonful made sense at the time. Do it for 36 years and at some point you have to ask if it’s still soup.
The ingredients so far. In 1999, 8 categories became 5. In 2014, powerful cars were sneaking into Cat A under the engine-size rule, so Cat A got a power cap: under 1,600cc and under 97kW. In 2022 we wanted more people driving EVs, so EVs up to 110kW were let into Cat A. In 2023 the ARF got steeper, up to 320% on the pricey part of a luxury car. So we auction the permit and tax the car. Add EV rebates (generous at first, now being wound down) and PQP renewals for when your 10 years run out.
Then the rules started bumping into each other.
If the Cat A line is 110kW, guess what power rating the new EVs arrived with. Just under 110. In Parliament on 3 November, Minister Siow said it plainly: EV power outputs can be adjusted with software. It’s legal. Car makers are doing exactly what the rules reward. Your car goes on a diet before weigh-in.
So fast premium EVs now sit in the same lane as the humble family sedan, and they bid against each other. That’s a big part of why small cars now cost more than big ones. One rule pushes one way, another rule pushes the other, and this is the result.
The money got gamed too
Normally you can borrow only 60 to 70% of a car’s price. Private-hire cars counted as commercial vehicles, so those limits didn’t apply.
Cue the ads. 100% loan, zero down payment, guaranteed approval. When The Straits Times checked earlier this year, 4 out of 5 dealers were willing to offer full financing, and some told buyers to register as a private-hire car just to get the bigger loan. Suddenly a lot of Singaporeans discovered a deep passion for driving Grab.
MAS says individual-owned private-hire registrations went up to about 500 a month, and some of those buyers had no intention of driving anyone anywhere. On 30 October, MAS closed the gap.
Why this matters for COE: it’s an auction. What you can bid depends on what you can borrow. Make borrowing easier and you’ve quietly added bidders with deeper pockets. A loan rule, a commercial-vehicle exemption and an auction all crashed into each other. The fix? Another rule.
Other cities, same squeeze
Singapore prices the right to own a car. Most cities price where your car sleeps, or where it drives.
Hong Kong has no cap on the number of cars. Instead there’s a first registration tax of 46% to 132%. Painful, but there’s no auction: you walk into a showroom and you know the price. The pain comes later, at parking. A monthly spot at a government car park in Central is about HK$4,850, roughly S$800, every month.
Tokyo is my favourite. Since 1962, Japan has had one simple rule. No parking, no car. Before you register a car you prove you have a space within 2km of your home, and you can’t park on the street overnight. A space in central Tokyo runs roughly S$240 to S$400 a month. Pricey, but you know exactly what you’re paying for. Space.
Shanghai is our closest cousin. They auction licence plates too. October’s average was about S$18,000, the plate doesn’t expire, and it moves with you to your next car. For many pure-EV buyers, the plate is free. They went simpler.
We tax the car, auction the permit, and then charge you to drive into town, because we also invented road pricing: the Area Licensing Scheme in 1975, ERP in 1998, and ERP 2.0 becomes compulsory in January 2027. So do we really need both a car auction and road pricing to do the same job?
The fair counterpoint: most of us park in HDB car parks, priced like a public service. A Tokyo-style “show me your parking space” rule would hit heartland car owners hardest. Copying Japan comes with its own bill.
The Corolla test
Take one of the most “uncle” cars in Singapore, the Toyota Corolla Altis. 1.6 litres, firmly Cat A. The car you buy so you never have to think about cars again.
With COE, it’s somewhere around $200,000 right now. For a Corolla.
MAS lets you borrow at most 70%, over at most 7 years. So you need about $60,000 in cash just to start, then roughly $2,000 a month for 7 years, depending on your interest rate.
The median full-time worker in Singapore earned about $5,775 a month last year, including employer CPF. So the COE alone is about two years of a typical person’s gross pay. Two years of work for permission.
Here’s the comparison that stings. The cheapest flat in the November BTO launch, a 2-room Flexi in Tengah, starts at $131,000 before grants. The COE costs more than the flat. The flat comes with a 99-year lease. The paper expires in 10.
In Tokyo, if you’ve got a parking space, a kei car costs not much more than a nice holiday.
The next fix
LTA has just wrapped up a public consultation. The idea: merge Cat A and Cat B into one category, then add a “feebate”. Cheaper cars get a rebate, luxury cars pay a surcharge, up to $15,000 either way, most likely in 5 bands. Findings are due in the first half of 2027, and the minister was clear nothing’s been decided.
On paper, I get it. If kilowatts are being gamed, sort by price.
My worry is a marketer’s worry. Incentives get priced in. Picture an auction with a fixed number of seats, then hand every bidder a $15,000 voucher. A lot of that voucher ends up in the bid. The price goes up, and the government collects a chunk of its own rebate back through higher COE bids. MP Tin Pei Ling asked exactly this in Parliament.
It’s also worth knowing what’s at stake. COE has brought in about $5 billion a year on average over the past decade, and closer to $9 billion lately. Quotas follow deregistrations, so I doubt the money is why it’s designed this way. But a system that earns that much doesn’t feel a lot of pressure to change.
Let’s go further
Honestly, if we’re going to keep adding rules, let’s do it properly. Make COE like BTO.
First-timer? You get a grant. One time only, use it wisely. There’s an income ceiling, of course, and a ballot. You apply, wait three and a half years, then collect your Toyota. Once you have it, there’s a minimum driving period of five years. You can’t sell it. You can’t rent it out. You must drive it yourself. Second car? Resale levy.
You laugh, but somewhere in a ministry, someone just took notes.
Every one of those ideas sounds sensible on its own. That’s how we got here. One sensible tweak at a time.
There are simpler options that have been floating around for years. Back in 1994, two NUS academics asked why we don’t bid a percentage of the car’s price instead, so the Corolla guy isn’t fighting the Porsche guy on the same scale. There’s the Tokyo approach, tying cars to parking. Or lean harder on ERP, which we already have, and loosen the auction. None of them are perfect. But they all start from the question we keep skipping: what are we actually trying to ration? Road space, parking, or who gets to own a car?
Every change went in for a good reason. It’s always easier to add one more fix than to say the recipe needs a rethink, because that feels like telling the chef the soup is bad.
In 1990, COE fit on one MRT ride. Today the paper alone costs more than a flat in Tengah, and the next bidding round closes on 18 November. I’ll be watching which category jumps, and which ingredient goes in next.








